Now Part of the Amp America Family!
Dec. 9, 2024

928: BREAKING: Daniel Penny NOT GUILTY

In a landmark victory for self-defense rights, a Marine veteran's not-guilty verdict challenges media narratives and reinforces the fundamental right to protect oneself and others in dangerous situations.

What does it really mean when self-defense meets justice in America's most controversial subway case? The verdict that's igniting fierce debates about personal rights, mob justice, and the true meaning of protecting others has finally arrived.

 

 

Studio Sponsor: Cardio Miracle - "Unlock the secret to a healthier heart, increased energy levels, and transform your cardiovascular fitness like never before.": https://www.briannicholsshow.com/heart

 

 

In this breaking news episode, we dive deep into the monumental not-guilty verdict in the Daniel Penny case, exploring how this Marine veteran's actions on a New York City subway have become a watershed moment for self-defense rights in America. We break down the crucial details that led to this landmark decision and why it matters for every citizen concerned about personal safety.

 

Beyond the headlines, we examine the dangerous intersection of media narratives, public opinion, and justice. This episode exposes how mob mentality and social media pressure attempted to influence the legal process, and why the verdict represents a victory for due process over emotional outrage.

 

We tackle the broader implications for self-defense rights, analyzing how this case could impact future situations where citizens must make split-second decisions to protect themselves and others. Our discussion reveals why this verdict isn't just about one incident, but about preserving fundamental liberties in an increasingly complex world.

 

This explosive episode challenges conventional narratives and forces us to confront uncomfortable questions about personal responsibility, liberty, and justice in modern America. Whether you're concerned about self-defense rights or the influence of media pressure on our legal system, this is one analysis you can't afford to miss.

 

 

❤️ Order Cardio Miracle (https://www.briannicholsshow.com/heart) with code TBNS at checkout for 15% off and take a step towards better heart health and overall well-being!

☕ Elevate your morning routine with Colockum Craft Coffee (https://www.colockumcraft.coffee)! Use code BNS10 at checkout for an exclusive 10% off and experience the difference of small-batch, artisanal roasts.

📧Submit your Listener Questions and thoughts on our Challenge of the Week to brian@briannicholsshow.com to hear your questions and perspectives answered and shared each and every week! 

🎙️ WATCH The Brian Nichols Show, available on YouTube & Rumble. With over 915 episodes featuring local candidates, elected officials, economists, CEOs, and more, each show educates, enlightens, and informs.

🔗Follow Brian on social media: X.com/Twitter (https://www.briannicholsshow.com/twitter) & Facebook (https://www.briannicholsshow.com/facebook)

🔔 Don't forget to like, share, and subscribe to The Brian Nichols Show for more captivating interviews and insights into libertarian solutions for local problems!

 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Studio SponsorCardio Miracle: Your health is an investment - NOT an expense. -  15%off using code TBNS at checkout

Support our Sponsors!

Support the program with a one-time donation or join our Patreon!

Take our audience survey for a chance to win a "Don't Hurt People, Don't Take Their Stuff" bumper sticker! 

 

 

Transcript

Ladies and gentlemen, we have some incredible news breaking out of New York City today: Daniel Penny has been found not guilty! That’s right—the jury has spoken, and justice has prevailed. This is a monumental win—not just for Daniel Penny but for anyone who believes in self-defense, personal responsibility, and standing up against mob-driven narratives.
Now, let’s be clear—this case was about more than just one man’s actions on a subway. It was about whether we, as a society, are still willing to stand up for the principles of individual liberty and due process when they’re under attack from emotional outrage and media pressure. So today, we’re going to break down what this verdict means for self-defense rights, why it’s a victory against mob justice, and what we can learn from it moving forward.
Section 1: The Case Recap and Why It Matters (2 Minutes)
Alright, let’s quickly recap what brought us here. Back in May 2023, Daniel Penny—a Marine veteran—was riding the subway in New York City when he encountered Jordan Neely, a man who was reportedly behaving erratically and threatening passengers. Penny stepped in to protect himself and others, restraining Neely in a chokehold that tragically resulted in Neely’s death.
Now, here’s where things got complicated. Despite multiple eyewitnesses confirming that Neely was acting aggressively and that Penny was trying to protect those around him, activists and media outlets immediately painted Penny as a villain. They called him everything from a vigilante to a murderer—and before you knew it, he was charged with manslaughter.
This case became a flashpoint because it wasn’t just about what happened on that subway—it was about whether we still value the right to defend ourselves in public spaces. If Daniel Penny had been convicted, it would’ve sent a chilling message to anyone who dares step up to protect themselves or others in dangerous situations.
Section 2: The Importance of Self-Defense Rights (3 Minutes)
Let’s talk about why this verdict matters so much—starting with self-defense. At its core, self-defense is one of the most fundamental rights we have as individuals. It’s the idea that you have not only the right—but also the responsibility—to protect yourself when your life or safety is threatened.
If we lose that right—or if we allow it to be eroded by fear of prosecution—then what kind of society are we left with? One where people are too scared to act when danger arises? One where law-abiding citizens are punished while aggressors face no consequences? That’s not liberty—that’s chaos.
And let’s not forget how this ties into broader issues like gun rights or stand-your-ground laws. Cases like Daniel Penny’s remind us why those protections exist in the first place: because sometimes you don’t have time to wait for help or rely on someone else to save you. Sometimes you have to act—and when you do, you shouldn’t be treated like a criminal for doing so.
This verdict sends an important message: If you act responsibly and within reason to protect yourself or others, our legal system will back you up—even if the media doesn’t.
Section 3: The Fight Against Mob Justice (3 Minutes)
Now let’s address another major theme in this case: mob justice—and why it’s so dangerous.
From day one, Daniel Penny wasn’t just facing legal charges—he was facing trial by public opinion. Activists were protesting outside courthouses. Social media was flooded with hashtags calling him everything from racist to murderer before any evidence had even been presented in court.
This is what happens when we let emotions override facts—and it’s something libertarians need to push back against hard. Due process exists for a reason: so that everyone gets a fair trial based on evidence—not on who can shout the loudest or generate the most outrage online.
And let me tell you—this isn’t just about Daniel Penny. We’ve seen this play out time and time again in high-profile cases where public pressure tries to dictate outcomes instead of letting facts speak for themselves. If we allow mob justice to become the norm, then no one is safe—not you, not me, not anyone who dares stand up for what they believe is right.
So how do we fight back? By staying principled—even when it’s unpopular—and by reminding people that justice isn’t about revenge or outrage; it’s about fairness and truth.
Conclusion (1 Minute)
Today is a good day for liberty—for justice—for all of us who believe in standing up for what’s right even when it’s hard. Daniel Penny is free because he acted responsibly to protect himself and others—and because our legal system upheld his right to do so.
But let me leave you with this: This victory doesn’t mean the fight is over. Cases like this remind us how fragile our rights can be when they’re under attack from emotional outrage or political agendas. So stay vigilant—keep advocating for self-defense rights, due process, and individual liberty—because these principles are worth fighting for.
Thanks for tuning into today’s emergency response episode! As always, if you found value here—or if you’ve got thoughts on today’s topic—drop me an email or hit me up on social media; I’d love to hear from you! Don’t forget to subscribe so you never miss an episode—and until next time, keep selling liberty by meeting people where they’re at!